Project Development

Archive images – perhaps unnecessary?


It has always been my intention, when photographing stained glass windows, to produce two distinctly different sets of images:

  • the first to demonstrate as accurately as possible the full visual impact of the window (focussing on the main subject of the window, not necessarily including the window or light in its entirety; edited initially to capture the full dynamic range and then digitally corrected to remove any damage as well as removing the horizontal support bars).
  • the second image (or batch of images) would be of the entire window or light,  for insurance / historical / academic research archive purposes.

Various recent experiences suggest that I cease with this second exercise.  Unusually, I have received no follow-ups from my communications with three of the most appropriate bodies where archive work is concerned (The British Society of Master Glass Painters, the V&A Museum and York Glaziers Trust).  It would only seem sensible and appropriate to continue this practice only following their advice and recommendations.  My discussions with the colleges I have visited points towards an already established archive recording of the windows.

While I will not yet throw out the idea of taking archive images, it does appear unnecessary and unless I can gain a steer from a professional body, the action may prove fruitless.

Project Development

Digital removal of support bars


Henry Holiday cartoon windowRemoving the horizontal support bars from a stained glass window image is definitely contentious.  After all, the vidimus, (the approved design of a window; an example is shown to the left) will have included these metal bars – they are very much part of the design.  However, they do mask window details and while a necessary evil, do detract from the composition of the artwork.

I have worked hard to remove the support bars from each of the windows I have edited.  It is a laborious and time-consuming process, but so far I have been successful in this work and the results are pleasing.  However, thus far this removal has for the most part been straightforward with the support bars covering comparatively plain segments of the window.  Unfortunately this is not always the case, with some windows featuring support bars which cover intricate and complicated detail.

IMG_2927 CROP lr

In the portion of window above, the removal of the support bar would be straightforward where it covers the orange/red and blue material; the stair-runner would be rather more demanding as would the basket.  However, the construction of two dove’s heads in the absence of any reference material would be unbelievably difficult.

02 - Cropped - CROPI stand by my belief that the edited images are dramatically improved following the removal of the support bars.  Thus it remains my intention to remove them when and where possible.  Perhaps my choice of stained glass window within a chapel, where choice is available, should be driven to some extent by this factor.  Where this presents  an almost 03 - Completed - The Lord is my Refuge CROPimpossible editing challenge, such as the bird basket above, then it would seem appropriate to leave the support bars in situ.  Frustratingly, I am prompted to type this having spent in excess of 10 hours thwarted by one section of support bar within an image from which I had already removed 60% of the bars!

Project Development

Glossary


  • Apse – the often domed, semi-circular or polygonal east end where the altar is located.
  • Calme or Came – Strip of lead H shaped to hold the pieces of glass together, from the Latin calamus, meaning reed.
  • Cartoon – A full size drawing of the design for a stained glass window.
  • Cinquefoil – A five lobed shape.
  • Design – See Vidimus.
  • Diaper – A decorative pattern applied using glass paint to enhance the glass surface.
  • Enamel – A technique developed in the late C15 to allow colours to be painted on to glass.
  • Ferramenta – The metal framework (iron, aluminium, copper, brass) fixed into the masonry to hold panels of stained glass.
  • Flashing – Application of a thin coat of coloured glass on to clear glass – most reds are flashed.
  • Grisaille – Clear or grey glass often decorated with foliage design
  • Grozing – A method of shaping the edges of pieces of glass to the right size using a metal tool known as a grozing iron.
  • Lancet – Tall, narrow windows with a sharp pointed arch at the top.
  • Light – The vertical division of a window.
  • Medallion – Circular panel of several pieces of glass leaded together.
  • Mullion – Upright stone section of a window. Divides the window into a number of lights.
  • Narthex – An antechamber at the western entrance of some churches, separated from the nave by a screen.
  • Nave – the central part of a church building, intended to accommodate most of the congregation.
  • Needlework – Fine relieving done with a needle or sharp instrument, scratching out.
  • Panel – An element of a stained glass window, generally no more than 1m square.  A single windows is, as a rule, made of several panels.
  • Plating – The doubling up of glass by the attachment of an additional layer, held together within a single lead. This can be part of an artistic technique, used as a means of modifying or intensifying colour or texture, or can be used as a protective measure during conservation.
  • Relieving – The removal of paint from the surface of the glass prior to firing, to allow light to come through; methods include needlework and stickwork.
  • Rinceau – Foliage design usually used as a background.
  • Rose – Round windows that often have elaborate tracery and lots of decorated stained glass. They are usually facing the altar.
  • Roundel –  A unipartite panel, generally round, bearing a self-contained design.
  • Quarry – (from French carré, square): a small pane of glass, usually diamond-shaped.  Imitation quarries are glass panels that have lead lines painted on them to simulate the appearance of quarries.
  • Quatrefoil – Windows with four petal shaped sections.
  • Stanchion – A vertical support bar set into the masonry, internally or externally (or both). Used in conjunction with Support Bars, which sometimes have eyes through which a stanchion can pass.
  • Stickwork – Relieving done with the end of a brush or blunt instrument, picking out.
  • Support Bar or Saddle Bar – A bar set horizontally into the masonry, to which stained glass panels are tied with lead or copper ties, supporting and preventing panels from flexing out of the vertical plane.
  • Tie Bar – See Support Bar or Saddle Bar.
  • Tracery – Ornamental stone openwork, typically in the upper part of a Gothic window.
  • Tracery Lights – The small, often ornate openings at the top of a window.
  • Trefoil – Windows with three petal shaped sections.
  • Vestibule – See Narthex.
  • Vidimus – Before the cartoon was drawn, preliminary sketches would be made to show what the finished windows would look like so the design could be approved. The approved design was the Vidimus.  The approved design of a window, before the cartoon is made.  Latin for “we have seen”.

Project Development

Dorneywood House


A slight deviation to my proposed Research Project found me at the country home of the Chancellor of the Exchequer.  Dorneywood House sits within 215 acres of beautiful gardens in the tranquillity of the Buckinghamshire countryside and was gifted to the Nation in 1942 by the philanthropist Lord Courtauld-Thomson.  The gardens are open to the public for two weeks each summer, but for security reasons photography is forbidden.  Pleasingly this ban was waived for my private tour.

Summerfield (low res)1874 saw the arrival of Courtauld-Thomson, the 137th pupil, at Summerfield (as was the name).  He moved on to Eton in 1879 and from there to Magdalen College, Oxford.  He decided to memorialise the key events of his life with a series of five stained glass windows and in the centre of the five is this lavish and rather touching tribute to his time at Summerfield.  Interestingly, his years at Eton and Magdalen College are squeezed onto a single, rather plain window – for which I spared very little time in post-production.

Dorneywood - Eton (low res)

M1 Wk9: Introducing Critical Theory

Activity: Critical Perspectives


I have always worried that my practice covers the broadest of canvases – photographically I am a Jack-Of-All-Trades but I rather hope that I am not Master of None. There is not a specific genre with which I feel a bond sufficient to state it as my preferred area of photography.  I am driven by an interest in, or enjoyment of the subject matter: my love of sports photography, particularly rugby and athletics, is shared by a passion for coaching both rugby and athletics, for example.  However, I can state absolutely that I have never enjoyed having to do portrait photography and this is mirrored by a dislike of having my photograph taken.

The area in which I have always received most criticism is my desire to preclude people from much of my work.  On returning from a family holiday, my parents continued be vexed by the absence of any family (or indeed anyone) from my photographs. For the most part, I find people an untidy distraction within a composition.  I have worked hard to acknowledge the existence of mankind – not least because I am expected to return from school trips with images of happy, smiling faces getting in the way of what I would actually like to capture.  So, by choice the photograph below of Menin Road South Cemetery would contain no children – an uphill challenge when you are traveling with 60 or more.  Light and composition were both favourable (composed specifically for social media) and as a candid shot, the four boys add something to it.  However, I am decidedly unhappy about the children in the background and almost did not use the image on those grounds alone: I just don’t like clutter in an image.

WQHF3029 sq

This is a theme carried over into my current practice: having photographed a stained glass window, I go to considerable lengths to ‘correct’ any clutter within the image.  While I leave flaws within the glass itself, cracks, stains, support bars and minor inconsistencies are removed.  There is a definite lack of properly representative images of stained glass within publications – a single photograph cannot handle the wide dynamic range, so it is typical to see bleached out areas and very dark areas: this is the attribute I most wish to improve upon.  My intention is to produce an image that shows a subtly heightened reality of the window.  Not a false representation, but an image that does not reflect tens or hundreds of years of dirt and possible neglect.

I have no doubt that purists would be highly critical of some (if not all) of these actions, but my hope is to present the images of stained glass windows as works of art in themselves, depicting something far more representative than seems commonplace when one looks for images of stained glass.  It is common practice to clean, physically, artwork within galleries, so perhaps my work will not suffer too many slings and arrows.

The challenges and complexities of gaining access to a location on a day that is appropriately bright but overcast, and then managing to photograph a series of 10-20 exposure bracketed of a stained glass window from a vantage point that minimises converging verticals, is not insignificant.  The pleasure of working in such fantastic surroundings is a good compromise, but with this particular practice, elaborate postproduction is critical and can involve days of work per window – the bias is significantly tilted towards the computer in contrast will almost all of my more usual work.  This is perhaps why I always have a nagging concern in the back of my mind, when working on a stained glass window image that I am somehow ‘cheating’ – image editing is stripping away the purity of photography.  Notwithstanding, since starting this course, I have already noted significant improvements in my attention to detail where precision in the set up of shots is concerned and greater efficiency in postproduction.

There is still a very long way to go and it is more than a little ironic that I have had to pause considerable areas of my photographic practice so that I can endeavour to keep my head close to the surface of this course: it is many weeks since I last did any photographic work within the school.  While this is in no way problematic, when one considers the concept of vanishing history, future researchers might ponder why the school’s archive is strangely devoid of images for a brief period!

Tutees in Photography

As a schoolmaster, it is always a pleasure to follow the progress of former Tutees.  It is usually difficult to imagine what they might do with their lives when they leave your care at the age of thirteen.  I am particularly proud of those who have succeeded within the field of photography:

Alex Barron Hough – Creative Production Director, TIGI


Alex B-H - Football Goal lrAlex’s involvement in photography started off the other side of the camera, modelling for catalogues.  (I suspect he will not forgive me for posting an image of him aged 12, from the Argos catalogue), but it was not long before he was working for TIGI Linea, becoming the face of their Bed Head for Men range.

Alex B-H (1)At the same time, he was developing the photographic skills that had first interested him at school, finding himself working both in front and behind the camera as a photographic assistant.

Today he is a routine fixture photographing backstage at Fashion Weeks in London, Paris, Milan and New York and is the Creative Production Director for TIGI UK, but he has also spent time in the recent past as the official photographer for The Who.

Rick Findler – Photojournalist


war_rickWith photography seeds sown at school, Rich (I have always known Rick Findler as Rich) developed an interest in photojournalism, with a particular penchant for conflict photography.  His work regularly features in leading publications and featured in the February 2018 RPS edition Journal.

I always enjoy receiving telephone calls from Rich which are often requests for help: lending a camera lens; sourcing ‘exotic’ hardware for his trips, such as respirators, military spec. laptops, etc., or perhaps  providing advice on some of the military hardware he has photographed.  In return, I am always fortunate enough to be included in a small group of friends and family who receive daily field reports from him, detailing and illustrating his work when he is out of the country.

Rich also works with The McLellan Practice as a school’s speaker on Conflict Photography from the Front Line.

Project Development

Oxford’s Chapels


To say that Oxford has a wealth of Chapels would be a huge understatement, with the list currently totalling 45 separate places of worship (or former):

Chapel Name, College (current chapel date) | dates of windows –

  1. All Saints Church / Lincoln College Library, Lincoln College (?) DECONSECRATED
  2. Bartlemas Chapel, Diocese of Oxford (1329)
  3. Chapel of Brasenose College, Brasenose College (1656)
  4. Chapel, St. Benet’s Hall (?)
  5. Christ Church Cathedral, Christ Church (1529) | C14; C17 – Bernard & Abraham Van Linge; C19 – William Morris & Edward-Burne Jones
  6. Church of St Peter-le-Bailey, St. Peter’s College (1874) | Henry Holiday / John Hayward / Ervin Bossanyi
  7. College Chapel, Corpus Christi College (1517)
  8. College Chapel, Jasus College (1621) | 1856 – Hedgeland
  9. College Chapel, St. Hilda’s College (?)
  10. Damon Wells Chapel, Pembroke College (1732) | 1884 – Charles Kempe
  11. Hertford College Chapel, Hertford College (1908)
  12. Keble Chapel, Keble College (1876) | 1876 – Alexander Gibbs
  13. Mansfield College Chapel, Mansfield College (?)
  14. St. Cross / Historical Collections Centre, Balliol College (?) DECONSECRATED
  15. St. John the Baptist, Merton College (1280) | 1289; C14; C15
  16. St. Luke’s Chapel, Radcliffe Observatory Quarter (?) DECONSECRATED
  17. St. Nicholas, Summer Fields School (1896) | 1896-1914 – Henry Holiday
  18. St. Paul / Freud arts café (1836) DECONSECRATED
  19. St. Peter-in-the-East / Library of St. Edmund Hall (?) DECONSECRATED
  20. The ‘new’ College Chapel, Exeter College (1859) | C19 – Clayton & Bell
  21. The Chapel of Harris Manchester College, Harris Manchester College (?) | 1893-1898 – William Morris / Edward-Burne Jones
  22. The Chapel, All Souls College (1440) | C15- John Glazier; 1861 – Hardman; C19 – Clayton & Bell
  23. The Chapel, Balliol College (1525) | C16; 1635 – Abraham van Linge; & 1912
  24. The Chapel, Lady Margret Hall (?)
  25. The Chapel, Lincoln College (1639) | 1641 – Abraham van Linge; 1861 – M. & A. O’Connor
  26. The Chapel, Magdalen College, Magdalen College (?)
  27. The Chapel, New College (1386) | 1386 – Thomas & John Glazier / Frankelen; 1735 – William Price; 1765-74 – William Peckitt; 1779 – Thomas Jervais
  28. The Chapel, Nuffiled College (1961) |1961 – Patrick Reyntiens
  29. The Chapel, Pusey House (?)
  30. The Chapel, Regent’s Park College (?)
  31. The Chapel, Somervile College (1935)
  32. The Chapel, St. Edmund Hall (C17) | William Morris / Edward-Burne Jones / Philip Webb
  33. The Chapel, St. Edward’s School (1878)
  34. The Chapel, St. Hugh’s College (1916)
  35. The Chapel, St. John’s College (1530) | Ervin Bossanyi
  36. The Chapel, University College (1629-31) | Abraham van Linge
  37. The Chapel, Wadham College (1610) | 1622 – Bernard van Linge / Evans of Shrewsury
  38. The Chapel, Wycliffe Hall (1896)
  39. The Oriel Chapel, Oriel College (1642) | 1767 – W. Peckitt; 1870 – Clayton & Bell; 1885 – H.E. Woodridgh; 2001 -Vivienne Haig & Douglas Hogg
  40. The Queen’s College Chapel, The Queen’s College (1719) | 1635 – Abraham van Linge;
  41. Trinity College Chapel, Trinity College (1691-4) | 1885
  42. Westminster Chapel, Oxford Brookes University (?)
  43. Worcester College Chapel, Worcester College (1720) | 1864 – Henry Holiday

 

  1. College Library, St. Anthony’s College (?) DECONSECRATED
  2. Library oriel, Harris Manchester College (?) DECONSECRATED

M1 Wk9: Theory in Practice 1

Forum: Theory in Practice


In reasoning why it is necessary to write the book Basic Critical Theory for Photographers, its author, Ashley La Grange, postulates the following:

“Many people are put off critical theory because they see it as difficult (often unnecessarily difficult), and cannot see its relevance to their own practical work.  The situation is not helped by the fact that much critical theory is written by academics, for other academics who are already familiar with the issues, vocabulary and earlier arguments.  The result is that critical theory becomes unnecessarily elitist and many people who would be quite capable of debating the issues are discouraged from doing so”.

Ashley La Grange (2005) Basic Critical Theory for Photographers. Focal Press.

For me, this statement encapsulates perfectly my current thoughts on critical theory – in my eyes this statement is effective theory in practice, critiquing critical theory.   Of course, Ashley sets out to dispel this belief and in fairness, I am yet to complete the 247 pages.  Having spent most of my University days in lab-based research, I have not previously had higher-academic circle time to share feelings.  The work I investigated and the writings I produced had to be entirely factual, scientifically proven with no place for subjectivity (although, scientific method does, I suppose, comprise two subjective components: forming hypotheses, and collecting data to substantiate or refute each hypothesis).

An analogy would be that of ordering wine in a restaurant – everyone is capable of expressing in their own terms what wine they would like to have with their meal, but many are terrified of embarrassing themselves by saying the wrong thing… so they pick out the recommended wine or ask the sommelier for a recommendation.  Here’s where I must come clean: I have studied with the Institute of Cape Wine Masters and am working slowly towards becoming a Winemaster – I routinely critique wines and have no problem with the associated issues, history, methodology and vocab.  I know the wines I like and I know theoretically what ought to make a good wine… but I cannot make wine and none of my critical practice has impacted any wine or the wine industry in any way.  So, does critical theory serve a valid purpose beyond humouring ‘academics’?

M1 Wk10: Theory in Practice 2

Forum: Theory in Practice


Images à la Sauvette

“We are passive onlookers in a world that moves perpetually. Our only moment of creation is that 1/125 of a second when the shutter clicks”.

Henry Cartier-Bresson (1952) Images à la Sauvette. Paris, Verve.

Cartier-Bresson held the fundamental belief that all elements of a photograph come together in a formal peak he referred to as “The Decisive Moment”. The world will pass everyone by perpetually, bit the creativity of a photographer will capture that moment to form the perfect image. The marriage of those elements will include all of the obvious, tangible aspects (light, location, time of day, composition, depth of field, perspective, an appropriate camera and lens), but also the lifetime of baggage carried by the photographer. Life experiences, instinct, anticipation and knowledge play a vital role in creating any decisive moment photograph. With this comes the Gestalt Psychology which Cartier-Bresson rather more handily termed “geometry”; in essence the way our eyes decipher an image: the innate desire for balance and a sense of order. As he puts it, “In photography, visual organization can stem only from a developed instinct”.

The choice of the word ‘creation’ reflects this inference that a photographer has to have experience in order to be effective

X-Ray photography

 SPECIATION – Still A Camera


Photographer Kent Krugh’s project Speciation is a series of X-ray photos of cameras that provides a brief history of photography, as told through the evolution of the camera.

“This work uses x-rays to explore the micro-evolution of cameras and is a metaphor about the limits of evolution,” Krugh writes. “While form and media may have changed, the camera is still a camera: a tool to create images by capturing photons of light.”

While the basic concept of what a camera is and does has not changed, the outward appearance and inner workings have, and Krugh’s images offer a look into the wide range of camera designs that have appeared over the years.

“While making these x-rays, I have been surprised and astonished by what I found inside the cameras,” Krugh says. “[A] camera is still a camera, though tremendous diversity exists.”

31-Canon-AE1-00131 Canon AE1 2018 © Kent Krugh

18x24-typology-1.0-2000x1500-72dpi

Speciation of Cameras 2018 © Kent Krugh