Project Development

St. George’s Cathedral, Cape Town


At more than 8000 miles from Oxford, and substantially too large to be a chapel, St. George’s Cathedral, Cape Town is definitely off-piste where my research project is concerned.  However, located immediately across the road from my hotel, it seemed foolish not to venture within.  It provided me with the opportunity to experiment with more straightforward image capture ( using an iPhone 7 and Canon G3X) as well as providing me with the opportunity to expand the reach of my Instagram site beyond the confines of Oxford.  These images were captured with the aid of a tiny table-top tripod, placed on the floor, necessitating rather more correction of converging verticals than I would like. However, all such experiences, good or bad, help improve my technique and allow me to try techniques very different to my more usual work with full frame cameras.

Access to churches in South Africa is not always a matter of walking in.  While staying in Stellenbosch, several visits to the stunning Dutch Reform Church proved fruitless, as it was secured on each occasion.  St. Georges Cathedral required four visits before I gained access and even then, it was for just fifteen minutes.

The Cathedral Church of St George the Martyr, to give it it’s full title, is the oldest cathedral in Southern Africa and the mother church of the Anglican Diocese of Cape Town (the seat of the Archbishop of Cape Town).  Designed by Sir Herbert Baker, with the foundation stone laid in 1901, the cathedral replaced a church built in 1834 on the same site, and is still incomplete.  The stained glass windows are numerous and varied in terms of age, size, shape and style.  My brief visit could not possibly do the site justice.  Indeed I did not even see all of the windows – hardly surprising when I spend more than twice that time carrying out a planning visit to a small Oxford chapel!

IMG_7562 ce.jpg

Christ in Triumph over Darkness and Evil (Gabriel Loire, 1982) St. George’s Cathedral, Cape Town.

In memory of Lord Louis Mountbatten, the three lights of this window were sponsored by ex-servicemen and women. It was created by French artist Gabriel Loire and was initially installed as just the single central light, with the smaller lights commissioned once funds were available.  It is not often that I have the opportunity to compare a completed window with the vidimus, but the image below depicts the window as it was designed to be (sadly a very poor quality image), with a few notable differences to the window above.

St Geroges (vidimus).jpg

All of these images were captured at some speed, to the extent that errors were made.  While not to be repeated, the whimsical nature of the light trails coming from the rose window in the unedited image below does add an certain ethereal presence to the scene.

IMG_7556 lr.jpg

The Lady Chapel was added in 1962 and houses four lights by Francis Spear (and English stained glass artist and lithographer).  At the east end was a circular window above the alter, and to the west end were three smaller, rectangular lights:

In post production, I always remove the surroundings from the stained glass windows, but todays sojourn revealed one of the smaller lights in a setting where the illumination it provided extended its beauty beyond the confines of the glass, flowing onto the surrounding stonework.  It seemed appropriate to leave the image uncropped:

image1 ce lr

I do very much like the appearance of this image, and would happily peruse such things were I content to set aside months of my existing research and contact again all of the Colleges requesting to photograph their artwork in a different style and to a different end.  I have previously explained that the bright light that generates such images is detrimental to the work I set out to achieve as it creates significant shadow (Into the sun): bright sunlight is no friend to the process I have adopted.


It is both wonderful and fascinating to observe the projections of light – it plays into the scientific nature of my brain: almost any child will tell you about the creation of a rainbow as white light passes through a prism… if educated appropriately the will go so far as to explain about the refraction of light.

For me, looking at the light traces that have passed through stained glass, I always wonder how many people consider the effect that the coloured glass is having on the beams of light: while they may well appreciate that glass has an influential effect on the light, I wonder if they realise that the position of the beam will have been influenced further by the colour of the glass?  Consequently the light passing through red glass, for example, will create red beams that have shifted a very small amount further because the absorption of blue light, green light, and indeed all of the other colours of light: red glass has a minutely different refractive index to plain glass.

That change in refractive index (that is to say, the change in angle of light beam) will be different for each different colour of glass.  Put another way… a lump of glass will cause a light beam to refract (bend) a certain amount; a lump of glass with identical physical properties, but of a different colour, will cause the light beam to refract very slightly differently because some of the light is being absorbed into the glass.  The greater the amount of light absorbed by the glass, the greater will be the change in refractive index (the amount of bend) of the beam of light.

To add further complexity, the colour temperature of the daylight passing through the glass will also influence the angle of refraction.

To me, that is properly interesting science, well worthy of investigation.  However, it would not make for particularly interesting photography.


The lights either side did not share this effect, as a result of partial shading by trees, so I cropped them as I would were they part of my portfolio:

Should I ever wish to extend my project, there is clearly a huge diversity and wealth of stained glass that could be revealed, particularly in a country such as South Africa, where security concerns force churches to remain closed when there is no service taking place.

Instagram

@dpplimited


Instagram LogoWhile progress is slow in my global domination of social media, the number of followers to my Instagram site is growing gradually, with a small number following almost immediately after I uploaded three images from St. George’s Cathedral, Cape Town (each of whom came through the #capetown route).  Clearly, finding new angles to the presentation of my research (specifically and only for social media), in addition to the progressive addition of new posts, is a route to follow.

Context is always important: working for CEOP, I am very much involved in the online protection of children and teach routinely about this.  During a recent Tutorial, immediately following such a lesson, one of my Tutees (somewhat of a celebrity), who is only just old enough to have an Instagram account, revealed that he currently has over 52K followers… more than 1000x that of my account!

Light Installations

Liz West


I was fascinated to see Liz West‘s work – quite extraordinary.  Undoubtedly very costly to stage, enormously time consuming and very clever.  Witnessing her installations would be mightily impressive and memorable.  The use of light interacting with materials appeals to me because I understand the physics behind it and am also aware of the impact that different colours can have on human behaviour – to me it is a clever scientific statement and it seems that this is also the intention of West.  However, I suspect there are many who are desperately trying to find some pseudo-intellectual interpretation of the installations to impress their peers.

Liz_West_Our_Colour_Reflection_01_Klaus_Bossemeyer.jpg

Liz West (2016) Our Colour Reflection

Much as I like West’s work and appreciate that a parallel can be drawn between it and my own project, the significant reason behind me wanting to follow my path is that it is my path, not someone else’s.  So far as post production is concerned, it would be straightforward for me to photograph the interaction of light passing through stained glass windows as it plays on the interior of a chapel – my camera would capture it beautifully either as stills or in 4K 60fps.  I have ready access to a smoke machine and a hazer which could reveal further the beams of light through a ‘misty’ interior.  Such work would require a little more prep. time and once again would require a very specific level of light intensity.  Sadly through, the size of most chapels is such that their interiors are never sufficiently dark for stained glass to paint wonderful daubs of coloured light on the interior – the colours are bleached out by the ambient light.

I will include an image within my Work in Progress Portfolio that gives a nod towards West’s work, depicting the interaction of light through a stained glass window that I discuss in more detail HERE.

image1 ce lr

This does lead me on to a pertinent point, for which I therefore have further thanks for the stimulation that West’s work has provided.  Always mulling over in the back of my mind is how best to exhibit my work.  While it is highly probable that I will opt for regular printing on art paper, I do very much like to idea of light boxes or perhaps computer/tv screens – I can vouch for the stunning quality of my work on my own Panasonic 55″ OLED television.  However… I would be very interested indeed to see my work as an installation on Philips Ambilight TV, where the colour of the image is projected onto the wall behind the television.  It would be fraught with technical difficulties and compromises, as I would have to crop each image to full-screen 1080HD or 4K resolution, but it could be very interesting.

Philips Ambilight.png

© Philips Ambilight (2016)

It is even possible to retro-fit similar technology to televisions or computer screens using third-party alternatives – a technology referred to as Boblight, readily available on eBay. However, Philips has moved forward, replacing the LEDs with nine Ambilight pico-projectors that mimic the overall motion and shape of the objects on the screen – available on their AmbiLux range (which interestingly does not employ OLED technology). This is a properly exciting prospect that would allow my images to spread into the gallery space. However, the £2500 price is likely to prevent me benefitting from the AmbiLux screens!

Philips AmbiLux 01 (615)

© Philips Ambilight (2018)

 

Project Development

Mansfield College Chapel


Mansfield - Johannes Balliolo (vlr).jpgIt is only now, five weeks after visiting Mansfield College Chapel, that I have had the chance to review the images.  With limited time available this weekend, I selected the only east wall stained glass window that could be photographed.

A batch of twenty images covered adequately the dynamic range.  The postproduction work was fairly straightforward, with just two support bars to remove.  However, the window was dark and very dirty for something less than 125 years old, resulting in an image that underwhelms.

Perhaps unusually, this window celebrates the founder of Balliol College: John de Balliol and his wife Dervorguilla of Galloway.

Inscription: John de Balliol; Dervorguilla of Galloway, Mistress of Balliol, Founders around 1269

Project Development

Harris Manchester College Chapel – Angels


I have commented extensively on the stained glass of The Chapel of Harris Manchester College and in particular its East Window.  Having previously edited the rose ‘Teaching the Ignorant’ I was drawn to the selection of angels that that flank the rose.

I have yet to find a detailed guide to tracery in order to identify and name, appropriately, the various parts of a church window.  Notwithstanding, below are edits of these beautiful, yet subtle components of the window.  I have cropped each as a square to optimise their use on Instagram, but also because they might lend themselves to greetings card design.

HMC - Angel Left (low res)HMC - Angel Right (low res)HMC - DCP_8711 sq (low res)HMC - DCP_8691 sq (low res)HMC - DCP_8734 c qs (low res)

East Window tracery lights (BJ237 Edward Burne-Jones, 1896) The Chapel of Harris Manchester College

We remember them…

Light boxes


Gosport’s War Memorial Hospital has had a chequered history in recent years, making the headlines for all the wrong reasons.  However, this week a positive snippet of news came thanks to the support of Gosport War Memorial League of Friends.

The hospital was built in part with contributions from the Royal Marines and has, to this day, been a memorial to those killed in action.  To celebrate the 100th anniversary of the end of the First World War, three back-lit stained glass lights were commissioned.  Crafted by Sunrise Stained Glass, Southsea.

Sunrise Stained Glass

© Sarah Standing (2018) Gosport War Memorial Hospital stained glass

This is the first example of back-lit stained glass that I have seen and it is a concept that I have considered for my work.  For years this has been used widely in advertising, and with the ever falling price of LED strip lighting, this might become an option for me (although unless the Lottery is kind, I cannot imagine that I will be able to afford more than one or two such units).

While there are many companies proffering light box solutions and I have investigated a few at The Photography Show, one of the better is LiteHouse, who have produced a number of significant commercial installations in addition to a few specifically for stained glass.

Project Development

University College Chapel


Best known for its windows by Dutch artist Abraham van Linge, it seems somewhat ironic that today’s visit saw me photograph none of those.  Sadly the lighting was too bright and harsh to capture any of the south windows and as a result of this, the north windows were too brightly lit internally by the other windows.

Univ - Chapel (low res)Univ - Chapel 02 (low res)

This only left me with the ‘new’ east window.  For the first time, I opted to capture all five of the main lights within the window as they tell the story of the crucifixion in its entirety.  In addition to this, and in keeping with most of my visits this Module, I photographed a number of the angels that make up the reticulated tracery at the top of the window.

Univ - Rose - Left Angel (low res)Univ - East Windows - Centre Angels (Low Res)Univ - Rose - Right Angel (low res)

Scenes from the Passion – Angles (Arthur & Michael O’Connor, 1864) University College Chapel

These images were shot at 400mm using the Canon EF 100-400mm f/4.5-5.6L IS II USM lens, at an aperture of f/8.0 and exposure times ranging from 1/50 s to 1/2 s.  Currently I have yet to start editing the main lights, but will post an update once it is complete.

I plan to return to photograph other windows within the chapel when the light is more favourable, although am inclined to capture the Adoration of the Magi (Clayton & Bell, 1866) rather than one of the van Linge’s, since this will tie in with my plan to generate a supplemental portfolio of image appropriate for use in the production of a collection of Christmas cards.

Project Development

University College Chapel – East Window


My first stab at (almost) an entire window warrants a before and after look.  I was ambivalent about the support bars, and despite there being only two or three per light, I opted to leave them in as they do not detract (much) from the image.  Now, as I type this, I find myself questioning that decision.  Perhaps at a later date I might re-edit the image, but for the time being they remain.

Univ - East Window - Scenes from the Passion (low res) BEFOREUniv - East Window - Scenes from the Passion (low res)

Scenes from the Passion (Arthur & Michael O’Connor, 1864) University College Chapel

This blog does not do the five lights sufficient justice, so below is the window split into three, running from left to right:

Univ - East Window - Scenes from the Passion (low res Left)Univ - East Window - Scenes from the Passion (low res Centre)Univ - East Window - Scenes from the Passion (low res Right)

I am surprised by the lack of support bars – based upon previous experiences, I would have anticipated four or five per light, but instead there are two or perhaps three, with an extensive area of unsupported glass in the middle.  Perhaps this is a feature of Arthur & Michael O’Connor lights – as these are the first that I have (knowingly) seen, it is hard to tell without further research.

The presence of two candelabras necessitated the photograph to be taken from an off-centre position to the left of the window, leaving the candelabra chain running between the fourth and fifth light.  The existence of raised pews and high kneelers at the west end facilitated a pleasingly high tripod location, some 4m off the ground.  As a result, there was only minimal post-production perspective control required, with a minor amount of converging verticals and not too much horizontal convergence, with the degradation in image quality being difficult to notice.

A total of 18 images were shot at 148mm using the Canon EF 100-400mm f/4.5-5.6L IS II USM lens, at an aperture of f/8.0 and exposure times ranging from 1/50 s to 1s.

Project Development

Why do it?


Univ GIF

‘There is considerable emphasis on how much time it takes to make such images, which is appreciated but it merely raises more questions about why you choose to do it.’

I am a perfectionist whom enjoys the intellectual challenge of optimising the production of projects as far as it is possible to take them.  To that end, when I am setting up the shots within a chapel, I am always a little frustrated that I do not have something more like a Hasselblad H6D-400C MS for its outrageous resolution and a mobile aerial work platform to enable me to photograph at the height of the windows, so eliminating the need for post-production perspective control.

I believe, fundamentally, that postgraduate studies in photography should be a challenge photographically.  Within my project, I am using my experience, knowledge and understanding to produce images that are currently beyond the capabilities of cameras.  Me augmenting technology if you like.  Because cameras do not have the dynamic range to handle stained glass, there are precious few quality images out there (with the exception of those taken in museum collections, in which the glass has undergone expert cleaning and the unit is backlit by a light box of precise, known, colour temperature).  Such challenges make this work interesting.

I enjoy the challenge.  I am doing something that is innovative within its field, and I am cataloguing an aspect of a collection that did not even exist on paper until I created the list.

Project Development

Worcester College Chapel – Planning Visit


Perhaps stretching the truth a little: today I was singing evensong at Worcester College with the school choir, which cancelled out much of my half day, precluding my ability to work creatively on my project.  However, having sung here several times before, and already knowing the Chaplain, it did afford me the chance for some planning and a verbal request to photograph the windows.

Sadly, being an evensong in the winter months, it was dark by the time of my arrival in chapel, so my iPhone battled to drag any suggestion of light from the windows.  However, all is not lost…

Worcester_College_Chapel,_Oxford,_UK_-_Diliff (low res)

David Iliff (2015) Worcester College Chapel

The lavish appearance of the current chapel is thanks extensive renovation and redecoration work by William Burge, that started in 1863.  Its stained glass windows were to have been designed by John Everett Millais, but Burges rejected his designs and entrusted the work to Henry Holiday.


Surely that has to be a story in itself!  The fact that Burges rejected the designs himself would suggest, sadly, that they did not even get as far as the College, who would likely have archived them.  My penchant for Holiday’s work is no secret, but I am fascinated to know what might have been had Millais’ work been used.

Millais was no fool where Pre-Raphaelite art is concerned, perhaps best known for his oil-painting on canvas Ophelia, he became friendly with William Holman Hunt, whose famous work The Light of the World (painted at the same time as Ophelia), hangs in the Side Chapel of Keble College, Oxford.

N01506_10 (Ophelia) (low res)

John Everett Millais (1851-2) Ophelia ©Tate, London 2014

A moderate level of research reveals surprisingly sparse reference to Millais’ stained glass work, besides another oil painting Mariana, which features the stained glass of Merton College Chapel, Oxford.

T07553_10 Mariana (low res)

John Everett Millais (1851) Mariana ©Tate, London 1999

Stories within stories.  Definitely worth of further investigation, but not right now at the expense of my current research.


The chapel is unusually wide, which might afford some good photography of the windows that adorn the north and south walls – despite their height.  As is increasingly the case, the east window will prove most straightforward to photograph, with an uninterrupted view along the nave.

Worcester_College_Chapel,_Oxford,_UK_-_Diliff 02 (low res)

David Iliff (2015) Worcester College Chapel (tight crop)

With the support bars being an integral part of every window, it may prove sensible to preclude any removal from this location… the idea of editing out eight horizontal and two vertical bars is horrific!

After the service, the Chaplain kindly granted me open access to photograph the chapel windows whenever suits me, so I suspect that this will be one of my first visits in the New Year.

Looking at the exquisite image by David Iliff makes me realise that I should be recording a quality locational shot on each visit.  While this is something that I have been doing, for the most part, it has been a little half-hearted thus far.